I ordered these as a gift for a friend and was happy when they finally arrived. The red colour is not as pronounced as I would have liked or expected. They are more of an orangey-brown with lots of little black speckles. They're still very nice, but without as much of a pop.

Got these for myself at 1/2". Honestly, I was really disappointed; the cut is great and they feel very smooth when I put them in but they aren't red like the picture...at all; more of a terracotta brown with black speckles. 5 for quality, 2 for color, 3.5 for the average but there's no half marks so 3. BUT, this doesn't discourage me AT ALL in buying from OneTribe again.

Loved these! The flares seemed a bit extreme, but once my ears were comfortably at 1g, I was able to fit in these pieces at 2g. Lovely smooth color, like tomato bisque! Very comfortable and good weight.